This month we discuss what so many professionals miss with
their prospects and that often cause surprises after the project has
started.
It
is discussing the pains of change with clients. The problem is that
very often clients invite your to their sinking ships hoping that you
get their sinking ships into smooth cruising mode again within a day or
two, and often for a competitive(ly low) fee.And when this doesn't happen (According to Dr. Edgar Schein, over
90% of
consulting projects fail because of undisclosed events, non-discussable
and lack of action on clients' sides), very often consultants get
blamed for failing to achieve the projected results. But who is in the
driving seat? You or the client? Who is the decision maker? No, not you?
Thus final outcomes cannot be in your hands. And you must communicate
this to your clients.
However, making consultants responsible for
the outcomes of their clients' projects is just as futile as making
parents single-handedly responsible for their kids' accomplishments.
Consultants, just like parents, are not the ultimate decision-makers.
You
can't even guarantee whether or not your clients get out of bed in the
morning let alone whether they use or discard your advice. In plain
English: You are NOT in charge. The client is.
Regardless of what
parents do for their kids, and regardless of how much they help their
kids to achieve it, if the kids consciously DECIDE to get involved in
crime or drugs, the is not a dickybird parents can do about it.
Responsibility for achieving results and authority for making decisions
come hand in hand. You can't separate the two.
By nature people
are scared of the unknown aspects of change, and, interestingly, when
the change process is promoted to be a smooth ride and a neat slope with
a steady gradient, some people get excited and jumps on the
opportunity, but some people become extra cautious.
So, how does
the military handle total buy-in from new recruits? Read the next
paragraph from General Patton preparing his troops for battle.
"You
are not all going to die. Only two percent of you right here today
would die in a major battle. Death must not be feared. Death, in time,
comes to all men. Yes, every man is scared in his first battle. If he
says he's not, he's a liar."
The US Navy's SEAL
Unit vehemently promotes the most intense part of their training, called
"Hell Week". They tell potential recruits about all the pain and
suffering they have to endure in order to become full-blown members of
one of the most respected units in the American military machine.
And
guess what, when people are mentally prepared for the hardship, they
can better take it. And attrition rate in the military is a lot lower
than project failure rate in the world of consulting.
In the world
of professional services there is the current situation, the desired
situation and the unknown "swamp" clients have to go through to reach
the "promised land."
The key is to tell clients that it is a swamp
full of alligators and mosquitoes not a rose garden with colourful
butterflies, the journey to cross the swamp to the promised land will be
more of a tough hike with blood, sweat and tears than a pleasure cruise
with cute waitresses and celebrity hunks.
Clients know what is
happening to them right now, and often can get a concept of what can
wait for them in the promised land, but still, they are scared to death
of crossing the swamp. And since you have crossed many swamps many times
and arrived at many promised lands, you can tell your clients about
what to expect on the journey and what to take with them. You can
recommend them to take a rifle and a big knife, and leave their make-up
sets and iPods at home.
When I defected from Hungary in 1988 with
no money and no English, I knew I was in for a pretty rough ride. I knew
I could end up being deported right away or being dumped into a refugee
camp living like a rat until I would have a chance to find work and be
released to the normal world (a.k.a. the rate race. Oh these fiendish
vermin are everywhere). Just like me, many of my friends were fed up
with the communist system, but unlike me, in spite of knowing the
beauties and benefits of the promised land, they found the swamp too
scary to cross, and decided to stay.
Many prospective clients are
like that too. And the sooner they decide whether or not they are
willing to cross the swamp with you, the better it is both for your
piggy bank and sanity. Imagine you go through several meetings, write a
proposal and then the prospect pulls back. A sort of "projectus
interruptus" when a prospect withdraws before something "serious"
happens. Arrrrrg!
So, during your initial discussion you've
outlined and evaluated clients' cost of staying where they are right
now, and the value of getting to the promised land. This actually
establishes your value, which is a basis of your fees. (For more on this
see "It's All About Your Value: Service Professionals' Guide to
Setting, Raising and Safeguarding Fees"
So,
now clients is excited about the opportunities waiting for them at the
promised land, and mistakenly assume that you do all the necessary work
and you actually carry them on your back to the new destination. This
sets up false expectations, and if something unexpected happens (always
does), you get blamed for everything, including the Spanish inquisition.
So, let's start and communicate this pain of change.
Ask
prospects about their concern and worries regarding the change effort,
and then elaborate on each item to the level of details as necessary.
Then bring up whatever has been missed. If prospects express concerns
about mosquitoes only, then bring up the alligators. Tell prospects that
if they step off the path, the swamp can swallow them. These are not
scare tactics, like "Unless you buy my fire alarm system, your kids will
burn alive and you will hear them scream for the rest of your life."
This is different. Here you use fear to make a buying decision.
Your
prospects have already made a buying decisions based on their values.
All you do is just fill them in on the details of what may or may not
happen during the journey across the swamp. Take some time together to
discover all the perceived dangers. If they don't happen that's great,
but if they do happen and your clients are not properly prepared, then
they freak out like injured animals, they can become totally
unpredictable and you can be in pretty deep yoghurt. That is what some
clients demand their money back or threaten to take you to court. It can
be pretty nasty.
So, for a moment remember your first day at university.
"People, you may feel a bit crowded right but relax. In a few months half of you will be out of here."
So,
students understand that unless they are willing to work their butts
off, they will soon be out with no hope in hell to retrieve the tuition
they paid at the beginning of the course. And if they want to come back
later, they have to pay again.
The other important point is to
make buyers understand that before the situation improves, it will
worsen. It is the same as people shortly before dying often get
seemingly better get, and then without much fuss, song and dance they
irreversibly kick the bucket.
Therefore you must discuss the pains
of change while making the conceptual agreement with buyers. They must
know what they are about to get into. Remember, fear of failure is a
huge withholding power in people's lives.
In most organisations change takes place at five levels:
1. ASSET LEVEL: For
industrial organisations assets are the buildings, computer systems,
production lines, the fleet of company cars and the photocopier. For a
professional service firm it is their people. This is such basic change
as buying a new photocopier. However, some people may insist on keeping
the old copier because they are used to it.
2. ROAD MAP LEVEL: This
is plans, systems and processes that enable organisations to go from A
to B and actually navigate through the jungles of commerce throughout
its lifetime. The road map also includes, policies, procedures, code of
conduct, scripts and every piece of information that can be codified
into written documents. Change at this level seems to be easy, but at
this level we don't know whether or not people are interested in
changing at all.
3. CAPABILITY LEVEL: This is the skills
and competencies of the people organisations employ to produce what they
produce. This includes both explicit (learnt through memorising
information) and tacit (intuition, finesse, gut feeling, "trench work."
Basically cellular level knowledge) experience. Two police officers can
have the same level of explicit knowledge, but the one who has
personally led numerous raids on drug operations where the bullets were
flying has significantly more tacit experience.
This is why it is
huge mistake to hire people (employees, contractors or advisors) based
on resumes (explicit knowledge). I dare to say Donald Trump's assistant
knows more about real estate than most realtors out there who are
certified to the hilt and registered with every association that has
something to do with real estate. The person can be explicitly amazing
but tacitly amazingly incompetent. Your expertise is about 20% explicit
knowledge and 80% of tacit information (intuition and gut feeling,
trench work, basically cellular level knowledge).
The mistake here
is that by sending people to training courses, managers expect instant
performance improvement from their people as soon as they return from
the course. But people do need time to turn the new information into new
skills. For a doctor a fairly long time goes by between the first
anatomy lesson at medical school and the first real heart surgery. I've
never come across a doctor who can operate on people one day after
graduation. A law school graduate must be invited to the bar to
practise. It can only happen in the world of commerce that after
graduation a freshly minted MBA demands, and often receives a senior
management position with a corner office a personal secretary, some
mind-numbing bonuses (on what?) and a company Mercedes.
4. INTENTION LEVEL: This
is the major driving force behind and change initiative. It is fairly
easy to change things, but changing people is a horse of a different
colour altogether. We have discussed many times how important it is to
align organisational objectives and strategies with personal goals, and
this is the perfect place to see this alignment in operation. When it
exists, people buy into the change relatively easily (All right, let's
factor in the general fear of change), especially if they see that
everyone around them will go through the same change process.
For
every desire for change there is an opposing desire of keeping things
the same. At this point the best thing you can do is to find the pros
and cons for both situations.
5. VISION LEVEL: This is
really the essence of the change effort. Many people say "I want to
start exercising", but only a very few, who actually start, have
overarching reasons, let's call it visions, to actually get started and
maintain it in the long run. I know a company that espouses on its
website that they are the best IT firm in the vicinity, while the
president is encouraging people to do half-repairs, so they can return
and milk clients over and over again. He himself lives pretty high on
the hog and works hard on how to explain to his people why there is no
pay increase and, again, the company can't afford to pay bonuses.
Basically, he is a rotten lying SOB.
Post-Reading Provocation
*
Look back on your projects and try to count how many times your clients
have been surprised and even shocked by unexpected setbacks. Have you
ever been blamed for these setbacks?
* After discussing the
current and the desired situations, how could you discuss the potential
pain based on the five change levels listed above?
* How can you
communicate more effectively that creating the desired results, while
you and the client are mutually accountable to each other, is the
client's sole responsibility since s/he is the final decision-maker.